2 Girls, 1 Cup: The Show - 1 ª Season

Cup orders a toilet disguise so that he can live out his ultimate fantasy with Alyssa and Sarah. As he waits for the delivery, he helps train Sarah for an acting role in a local theater show. He builds the costume and orders laxatives. When Alyssa falls ill, signs direct her to Cup dressed as a toilet. She sees through the disguise but is convinced that Cup was merely auditioning for the play.

Gerome discovers Cup attempting to dive into the toilet and takes him for a ride a car. Gerome pulls a gun on Cup threatening to reveal Cup's secret to his roommates. After revealing that he is half-Cup himself, Gerome snaps. He returns to the apartment threatening the girls at gunpoint. Cup takes a bullet to defend the women. A police officer arrives and kills Jerome.

Cup visits a psychologist for post-traumatic stress disorder over his witnessing the death of Gerome. The psychologist recommends that he try to meet and socialize with other cups. A cup named Frenchy appears and flirts with Sarah. Frenchy tells Cup his plans for Alyssa and Sarah. Cup exposes Frenchy as a fraud. Frenchy pulls a knife and Alyssa steps on him.

Sarah is cleaning the bed when she discovers excrement under Cup's pillow. Cup freaks out and insists that it is not his. Herschel reveals that he has discovered Cup's father Fart and introduces him. Fart is crude and belligerent embarrassing everyone. Fart commits suicide and Cup vows to become a police officer. Cup becomes an undercover cop and kills a dealer after his partner is killed.

Cup welcomes his audience to his home. He announces that the show is taking a break from its normal story-line to focus on answering fan mail. Cup reveals his favorite food, his favorite hobbies, his favorite at home activity. his dispute with Suge Knight, his favorite movie, and other information.